The Help Desk

Your tough questions. MONEY's smart answers.
Presented by

How much can I withdraw from my converted Roth IRA?

October 11, 2012: 6:30 AM ET

Say I convert $100,000 each year from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA over five years. In the sixth year I will have converted $500,000 but only $100,000 will have been in a Roth for five years. Does that mean that in year six I can only withdraw interest or principal on $100,000 from the account, even though the total balance would be $500,000? – Tom C.

According to T. John Chase, managing director of TLP Advisors/Tax-Pros, Macedonia, Ohio, each $100,000 chunk you convert would be considered separate and have its own five-year waiting period before a qualified distribution could occur. Chase notes that the five-year IRA conversion rule that allows you to withdraw funds without an early withdrawal penalty only applies to withdrawals of contributions or conversion principal — not investment gains. (Chase also points out that there is a different five-year rule for regular contributions to a Roth IRA. With these contributions, the five-year clock starts ticking when you make the first contribution, and doesn't reset for every new contribution.)

Consider this example: If the $100,000 from your first rollover had generated $5,000 in earnings after five years, you still can't touch that $5,000 until you are 59 ½ or older. Otherwise you'll face a 10% penalty and income taxes on those earnings. "Of course, if you're 59½ or over, you're free to withdraw however much you want once the five years have passed," Chase says.

Chase cautions that making multiple conversions and withdrawals may attract the attention of the IRS. "So you can expect some correspondence from the IRS asking you to account for that money," he says. The burden will often fall on you to produce the paper trail showing that your conversions and withdrawals complied with the five-year rule and other regulations.

— Marc Mewshaw

 Got a question for the Help Desk? Send it to

Posted in: Uncategorized
  • What makes jewelry a good investment?

    They say gold, silver, or diamond jewelry is a good investment because its value will appreciate over time. But how can that be true if you can only sell jewelry to stores or pawnshops for a very bargain price? -- Lala, Astoria, Ore. /

    Much like a spiffy new car driven off a dealer's lot, most new jewelry purchases significantly depreciate as soon as you walk out of the store, says independent jewelry MORE

    Jun 8, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • Am I liable if my sons cause an accident?

    I have two sons, one living at home. Both of their cars are still in my name. Could I be liable for an accident? Should I transfer ownership to them? –G.V., Minneapolis

    In short: Yes and yes. "In almost all states, the title owner of an automobile can be liable for injuries that are caused by a driver," says Steve Gursten, a Michigan attorney who's president of the Motor Vehicle Trial MORE

    May 31, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • Can we refinance without much home equity?

    We have a second conventional mortgage on our primary (and only) home. When we purchased it, we used an 85-15-5 loan breakdown. We have since refinanced the primary mortgage, but are paying 8.4% on the second. Our loan-to-value ratio is too high to refinance the second loan and, since we are not facing a financial hardship, we are not eligible for a loan modification. What other options do we MORE

    May 10, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • Should a parents' financial information be included on a grad students' FAFSA?

    I have just been told I will lose my job effective March 31 because my company is closing this facility. My 21-year-old daughter is planning to attend graduate school next year and I am in the process of completing her FAFSA application. In trying to maximize her eligibility for financial aid, is it better for me to include the parental information or not? -- Name withheld

    When it comes to graduate school, MORE

    Apr 30, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • Does it make sense to put a lump sum into a 401(k)?

    Do companies match lump-sum contributions to your 401(k)? If not, does it still make sense to put a lump sum into a 401(k), provided you could still afford to make regular payroll contributions to the plan throughout the year to take advantage of company matches? -- Eric B., Charlotte

    Check with your employer's plan to see what is and isn't permitted. Federal law doesn't govern the speed with which employees can hit MORE

    Apr 27, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • What are some good low-cost index funds for my IRA?

    I want to start an IRA with low-cost index funds. Are there any with minimums as low as $1,000? —Jason Hartman, Canoga Park, Calif.

    You can find what you're looking for at Charles Schwab, which offers several low-cost stock and bond index funds with investment minimums of only $100 (for either IRAs or taxable accounts) and no upfront fees.

    Or, instead of piecing together multiple funds yourself, you can get an entire index MORE

    Apr 20, 2012 5:05 AM ET
    Posted in: Investing, Uncategorized
  • How can I lower my homeowner's insurance premium?

    My home insurance premium rose 19%. Why would that be, and what can I do? —Stan Prokop, North Attleborough, Mass.

    There are several reasons premiums might go up. Sometimes it's because you've made claims. At other times, increases are out of your hands, which looks like the case here: Massachusetts' insurance regulator says hikes followed "unprecedented" disasters in 2011, including tornadoes and a tropical storm.

    Your options: See if another insurer has a MORE

    Apr 3, 2012 5:05 AM ET
  • What's a good first credit card to help build my credit score?

    What's a good first credit card to build my credit score? Right now I use a debit card (and pay student loans).
    —A.L., Washington, D.C.

    Your strategy is sensible. Timely student loan payments help your credit score, but using a credit card responsibly will, after a ding for opening a new account, boost it further, according to the credit-scoring company Fico.

    If you can't qualify for a no-fee card, get a credit MORE

    Apr 2, 2012 6:00 AM ET
  • Would we benefit financially if we got married?

    My boyfriend and I will retire in about six years. Would we benefit financially if we got married? —Rae, Richmond

    Yes, most of the time. Married couples get many financial perks that are hard, if not impossible, for singles to duplicate. As a spouse you can draw on your deceased partner's Social Security benefits, in most cases, as long as the federal government recognizes your marriage (knocking out same-sex couples). You might MORE

    Mar 30, 2012 6:00 AM ET
Help Desk

Got a question about your money? We want to hear it! Each week we're answering your questions on CNN, Headline News and

Your email or phone number won't be published; we'll use it to get in touch if we need more information about your question.
Help Desk Video
  • NEXT
    Not enough money in America's 401(k)s
    Despite the surging stock market bringing balances to record highs, the average Fidelity 401(k) account has less than $100,000 in it. That's just not enough. Play
  • NEXT
    Explaining Obama's myRA
    President Obama unveiled a new savings plan for retirement accounts, aimed at encouraging people to start building their nest egg. But how exactly does it work? Play
  • NEXT
    Tricks on how to save in your 20s
    Saving for your retirement in your 20s doesn't have to be a financial burden. Prioritizing your expenses is usually the first step in building a nest egg. Play
  • BACK
    Don't get fooled by Black Friday sales
    Here are some of the tricks that retailers use to make you think you're getting a deal. Keep an eye out for them while shopping this Black Friday. Play
Best Tips
Some of the nation's leading business owners, investors, and thinkers share their thoughts on rebuilding your wealth. More
These strategies can help you manage the challenges -- both emotional and financial -- of helping an aging parent from afar. More
You don't need to be fanatical to get to 780. Those in the know say these moves matter most. More
Featured Newsletters

Tips for saving and spending smarter.

Search This Column
View all entries from this: Week, Month
Help Desk
More help for your career, your investments and your budget.
Powered by VIP.