The Help Desk

Your tough questions. MONEY's smart answers.
Presented by

Should I open a traditional IRA or a Roth?

March 9, 2012: 10:15 AM ET

I anticipate that my take-home income this year will be approximately $105,000. I contribute to my company's 401(k) and expect to max out at the 2012 contribution limit of $17,000. I am 29, single, and have approximately $48,000 in my 401(k). To be ahead in saving for retirement, I was told to open either a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA. However, based on my current income, projected salary growth, and income phase-out for each, I am not sure which, if any, is better. Should I open a traditional IRA or a Roth? -- Name withheld

All things being equal, financial experts love Roth IRAs. You can't deduct your contribution, but then your money grows tax-free and can be withdrawn tax-free in retirement. You're not required to take distributions once you hit age 70 1/2, and if you really need cash in an emergency, you can withdraw your original contribution without penalty after the money's been in the account for five tax years.

What's more, a Roth provides tax diversification in retirement, when withdrawals from plans like 401(k)s are fully taxable. "Some people put so much into qualified retirement plans that they don't have anything outside of that," says Constance Stone, a financial planner in Chagrin Falls, Ohio. "By the time they get to retirement, they're locked in."

You're probably still within the income limits for a Roth IRA. In 2012, if your adjusted gross income is less than $110,000 (as a single filer), you can contribute up to $5,000 to a Roth. The amount you can contribute goes down when your AGI is between $110,000 and $125,000 and ends completely at an AGI of $125,000 or more. So for now, it looks like you're in the clear. (Contribution limits are higher for married couples filing jointly: in 2012, they can make a full or partial Roth contribution with an AGI below $183,000.)

You definitely make too much to consider a traditional IRA -- eligibility phases out at an AGI of $68,000 for single tax filers who have an employer-sponsored retirement plan.

Once you make too much for either account, you have the option of a nondeductible IRA, which is exactly what it sounds like—you can't deduct your contribution. You'll pay taxes on any earnings in the account when you withdraw the money, but you won't pay taxes on your contributions, since you put in post-tax money. (If you open one, don't forget to file IRS Form 8606.)

You also have the option of saving money in a taxable account, such as an investment account at a brokerage or fund company. If you go that route, Stone recommends tax-efficient mutual funds or exchange traded funds (ETFs) to keep your tax burden low.

--Kate Ashford

Got a question for the help desk? Send it to

Posted in: Family Money, Investing
Join the Conversation
Help Desk

Got a question about your money? We want to hear it! Each week we're answering your questions on CNN, Headline News and

Your email or phone number won't be published; we'll use it to get in touch if we need more information about your question.
Help Desk Video
  • NEXT
    Not enough money in America's 401(k)s
    Despite the surging stock market bringing balances to record highs, the average Fidelity 401(k) account has less than $100,000 in it. That's just not enough. Play
  • NEXT
    Explaining Obama's myRA
    President Obama unveiled a new savings plan for retirement accounts, aimed at encouraging people to start building their nest egg. But how exactly does it work? Play
  • NEXT
    Tricks on how to save in your 20s
    Saving for your retirement in your 20s doesn't have to be a financial burden. Prioritizing your expenses is usually the first step in building a nest egg. Play
  • BACK
    Don't get fooled by Black Friday sales
    Here are some of the tricks that retailers use to make you think you're getting a deal. Keep an eye out for them while shopping this Black Friday. Play
Best Tips
Some of the nation's leading business owners, investors, and thinkers share their thoughts on rebuilding your wealth. More
These strategies can help you manage the challenges -- both emotional and financial -- of helping an aging parent from afar. More
You don't need to be fanatical to get to 780. Those in the know say these moves matter most. More
Featured Newsletters

Tips for saving and spending smarter.

Search This Column
View all entries from this: Week, Month
Help Desk
More help for your career, your investments and your budget.
Powered by VIP.